Humana Claim Denied: Step-by-Step Appeal Guide

Humana Claim Denied: Your Path Forward

Humana is one of the largest health insurance companies in the United States, with a major presence in Medicare Advantage (Part C), Medicare prescription drug plans (Part D), and employer-sponsored health coverage. Claim denials happen — but they are not final. Whether Humana denied a prior authorization, reduced your hospital claim, rejected a prescription drug coverage request, or denied a post-service claim, you have clearly defined legal rights to appeal.

This guide provides a complete, step-by-step walkthrough of the Humana appeal process for both commercial health insurance and Medicare Advantage, including how to escalate to external review and state insurance regulators.

---

Why Humana Denies Claims

Humana uses clinical guidelines and internal medical review processes to evaluate claims and prior authorization requests. The most common reasons for denial include:

Medical necessity. Humana's medical review team — or an automated clinical criteria system — determined that the requested service or treatment does not meet Humana's definition of medical necessity. This accounts for the majority of prior authorization denials and many post-service denials.

Prior authorization was not obtained. Humana requires advance approval for a wide range of services, including many specialist visits, procedures, diagnostic tests, and durable medical equipment. Services provided without the required prior authorization are typically denied.

Out-of-network services. If you received care from a provider not in Humana's network, coverage may be denied or significantly reduced (except in emergencies).

Step therapy protocol not followed. For prescription drug coverage, Humana may require you to try and fail a less expensive medication before approving a preferred or specialty drug. If this protocol was not followed, the drug claim may be denied.

Formulary exclusion. The medication is not on Humana's drug formulary, or requires a formulary exception.

Experimental or investigational treatment. Humana classifies the requested treatment as experimental or investigational and excludes it from coverage.

Claim coding errors. The provider's billing department submitted an incorrect procedure code, diagnosis code, or place of service code.

Coverage exclusion. The specific service falls within an explicit exclusion in your Humana plan.

---

Humana's Internal Appeal Process: Commercial Health Insurance

For employer-sponsored commercial health plans, Humana's internal appeals process complies with ACA requirements and ERISA (for employer group plans).

Step 1: Get the Details of Your Denial

Your Explanation of Benefits (EOB) or denial letter must contain:

• The specific reason for denial
• The plan provision or clinical criteria relied upon
• Your right to appeal and the deadline

If the denial letter is vague, call the member services number on your Humana ID card and request a detailed written explanation and a copy of your complete claims file.

Step 2: Request a Peer-to-Peer Review (for Prior Authorization Denials)

Before formally appealing, ask your provider's office to request a peer-to-peer review with the Humana medical director who made the denial decision. During this call, your doctor can present the clinical rationale for the treatment directly to Humana's reviewer. This is most effective for prior authorization denials and can sometimes resolve the dispute within 24–48 hours.

Step 3: File Your Internal Appeal

Deadline: Generally within 180 days of receiving the adverse benefit determination. Verify the exact deadline in your plan's Summary Plan Description.

How to submit:

• Online: Through MyHumana at humana.com under the "Claims & Costs" or "Appeals" section.
• By phone: Call the member services number on your ID card. Get the appeal reference number.
• By mail: Send to the Humana Appeals address provided in your denial letter. Send by certified mail and retain the receipt.
• By fax: Use the fax number provided in your denial letter.

What to include in your appeal:

• Your name, Humana member ID, and claim or authorization number
• A clear statement that this is a formal appeal of the adverse determination
• A detailed letter explaining why the denial is incorrect
• A physician's letter of medical necessity — this is the most important document. Your doctor should reference Humana's own clinical guidelines, specialty society guidelines (e.g., American College of Cardiology, American Cancer Society), and your specific clinical circumstances.
• Relevant medical records (office notes, test results, specialist reports)
• Peer-reviewed clinical literature if disputing experimental treatment classification

Humana's response timelines:

• Urgent/expedited appeals: Within 72 hours
• Pre-service appeals: Within 30 days
• Post-service (concurrent or retrospective) appeals: Within 60 days

---

Humana Medicare Advantage Appeals: A Separate Process

If you are enrolled in a Humana Medicare Advantage plan (Part C), the appeals process follows CMS (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services) rules, which differ from standard ACA commercial health insurance rules.

Level 1: Humana Organization Determination

For Medicare Advantage, the first step is an "organization determination" — Humana's initial coverage decision. If you disagree, file an appeal directly with Humana.

Deadlines:

• Standard appeal: Within 60 days of the coverage denial or Explanation of Benefits
• Expedited appeal (urgent): Within 60 days — Humana must respond within 72 hours

Level 2: Independent Review Entity (IRE) — MAXIMUS Federal Services

If Humana upholds the denial, your case automatically goes to an Independent Review Entity (IRE). As of 2025, MAXIMUS Federal Services handles Medicare Advantage IRE reviews. This is a free, independent review.

Contact MAXIMUS: maximus.com/en-us/federal-services

Level 3–5: ALJ, Medicare Appeals Council, Federal Court

Beyond the IRE, the Medicare appeals process proceeds through an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) hearing, the Medicare Appeals Council, and then federal court — as described in the standard Medicare appeals process. For full details, see our article on Medicare claim denials.

Part D Drug Denials

For prescription drug denials under Humana's Part D plans:

1. Request a coverage determination from Humana in writing.
2. If denied, file an appeal with Humana within 60 days.
3. Escalate to the IRE if Humana upholds the denial.
4. For urgent medication needs, request an expedited determination — Humana must respond within 24 hours for truly urgent cases.

For formulary exceptions (requesting coverage of a non-formulary drug), your doctor must submit a supporting statement demonstrating that the formulary alternatives are not clinically appropriate for you.

---

External Review: Commercial Health Insurance

For commercial health insurance denials involving medical judgment, you are entitled to an external review by an Independent Review Organization (IRO) after exhausting Humana's internal process. Key facts:

• External review is free for you.
• The IRO's decision is binding on Humana.
• You have 4 months from Humana's final denial to request external review.
• Expedited external review is available within 72 hours for urgent situations.

Your denial letter must include information on how to request external review. You can also contact your state insurance department for guidance on requesting an IRO review.

---

Filing a Complaint with Your State Insurance Regulator

If Humana has violated your rights — by failing to respond to your appeal within required timeframes, by denying a state-mandated benefit, or by engaging in claims handling practices that violate state insurance law — file a complaint with your state insurance department.

Key steps:

1. Document all communications with Humana (dates, names, reference numbers).
2. Locate your state insurance department at naic.org/state_web_map.htm.
3. File a formal complaint, attaching your denial letter, your appeal, Humana's response, and any other relevant documents.
4. For Medicare Advantage issues, also consider filing a complaint with CMS through medicare.gov or calling 1-800-MEDICARE.

State insurance departments can investigate and require Humana to take corrective action. In cases of bad faith claims handling, some states allow consumers to pursue damages beyond the denied claim amount.

---

Common Mistakes When Appealing Humana Denials

Not acting fast enough. The 60-day deadline for Medicare Advantage appeals and the 180-day deadline for commercial appeals may seem generous, but time spent gathering evidence reduces the time available to write a strong appeal. Act within the first two weeks.

Submitting a generic appeal. Humana's reviewers see hundreds of appeals. A letter that simply says "I need this treatment" will not succeed. Your appeal must address Humana's specific denial reason, point-by-point, with supporting clinical evidence.

Relying only on the denial letter. The denial letter is often a form letter. Request the complete claims file to understand exactly what evidence and clinical criteria were used, then challenge any factual errors or misapplications.

Not pursuing external review. Many people accept Humana's final denial and stop there. External review is free and reverses a meaningful proportion of upheld denials. Always use it.

Failing to request expedited review for urgent medical needs. If you are waiting for a treatment you urgently need, request expedited appeals at every level — Humana and the IRE must respond within 72 hours for urgent cases.

---

Get Professional Help with Your Humana Appeal Letter

A well-drafted Humana appeal letter directly addresses the clinical criteria Humana used to deny your claim, presents medical evidence persuasively, and frames the argument in terms of applicable legal standards. ClaimBack at claimback.app generates professional, targeted appeal letters for Humana denials based on your specific situation — whether your denial involves medical necessity, prior authorization, formulary exception, or experimental treatment. A strong letter improves your odds at every level of the appeals process.

---

Conclusion

Humana claim denials can be successfully challenged at multiple levels — through internal appeals, independent external review, state insurance department complaints, and for Medicare Advantage members, through the full Medicare appeals hierarchy up to federal court. The keys to success are acting quickly, gathering strong medical evidence from your treating physicians, addressing Humana's specific denial reasons point-by-point, and using every available channel. Begin with ClaimBack at claimback.app to generate your appeal letter, and do not give up until you have exhausted every option.