Insurance Claim Denied in Israel: Your Rights and Appeals Process

Insurance Claim Denied in Israel: Know Your Rights

Israel has a well-developed and heavily regulated insurance market. Whether you hold a life insurance policy (Bituach Chaim), health insurance supplemental coverage (Bituach Briut Mashlim), car insurance (Bituach Rechev), property insurance, or travel insurance, Israeli law provides policyholders with meaningful rights and formal channels to challenge unfair claim denials.

This guide explains the regulatory framework, why claims are commonly denied, and how to navigate the appeals process — from internal complaint to the Insurance Commissioner and the financial ombudsman (Pa'ar Ha'Din, or פה"ד).

---

Israel's Insurance Regulatory Framework

The primary regulator for Israel's insurance industry is the Capital Markets, Insurance and Savings Authority (CMISA) — in Hebrew: הרשות לשוק ההון, ביטוח וחיסכון. CMISA operates under the Ministry of Finance and supervises all insurance companies, pension funds, and provident funds in Israel.

CMISA Website: https://www.gov.il/he/departments/capital_market

CMISA Hotline: *3002 (toll-free in Israel)

Address: 31 Kaplan Street, Jerusalem 91710, Israel

Within CMISA, the Insurance Commissioner (Hamefakech al Habituchim) specifically oversees the conduct of insurance companies toward policyholders, sets minimum standards for claims handling, and can investigate and sanction insurers.

In addition to the regulatory complaint process, Israel has a dedicated Financial Ombudsman — formally known as the Pa'ar Ha'Din (פה"ד, or Netziv Tlunotot b'Finansim) — that provides free, independent dispute resolution for financial services complaints, including insurance.

---

Why Insurance Claims Get Denied in Israel

Common reasons for insurance claim denial in Israel include:

1. Non-disclosure of medical history. Israeli health insurance and life insurance applications require detailed disclosure of medical history. Insurers frequently deny claims citing alleged non-disclosure of pre-existing conditions. Under Israeli law, the duty of disclosure is governed by the Insurance Contract Law of 1981 (Chok Chesei HaBituach), which sets the standard for what constitutes material non-disclosure.

2. Policy exclusions. Israeli insurance policies commonly exclude:

• Pre-existing conditions for new health insurance policies (often for a waiting period)
• Sport and adventure activities (for travel and personal accident insurance)
• Damage caused by intentional acts
• Losses arising from criminal activity

3. Disagreement on the value of loss. Property and vehicle insurance disputes frequently arise over the valuation of damaged property or vehicles. Insurers use their own assessors; policyholders are entitled to obtain independent assessments.

4. Car insurance fault disputes. Israel's mandatory third-party motor insurance (Bituach Chova) is administered under the Road Accident Victims Compensation Law. Additional comprehensive motor coverage disputes arise over fault allocation and repair cost disagreements.

5. Causal link disputes. In life and disability insurance, insurers sometimes deny claims arguing that the cause of death or disability was not an insured event (for example, arguing that a death was caused by a pre-existing condition rather than an accident).

6. Late claim notification. Many Israeli insurance policies require prompt notification of loss — typically within 30 to 90 days. Late notification can be used as grounds for denial.

---

The Insurance Contract Law (1981) — Key Provisions

The Insurance Contract Law of 1981 (Chok Chesei HaBituach, 5741-1981) is the cornerstone of policyholder rights in Israel. Key provisions relevant to claim denials:

• Section 6: The duty of disclosure — the policyholder must disclose all material facts known to them. However, the insurer's right to deny coverage for non-disclosure is limited if the omission was not material to the insurer's decision to underwrite the risk.
• Section 21: Insurers must pay valid claims promptly — within 30 days of receiving all required information. Delayed payment attracts interest.
• Section 28-31: Regulation of policy exclusions — exclusions must be clearly brought to the policyholder's attention. Exclusions that were not adequately disclosed may be unenforceable.
• Section 54: A policyholder who has already paid a premium may continue coverage even if the insurer later discovers grounds for avoidance, in some circumstances.

---

Step-by-Step: How to Appeal a Claim Denial in Israel

Step 1: Request a Written Explanation

Always start by requesting a complete written explanation of the denial from your insurer, citing the specific policy clause and the factual basis for the decision. Under Israeli insurance regulations, you are entitled to this.

Step 2: Submit a Formal Internal Complaint

Write a formal complaint to your insurer's complaints department (Ma'arechet Tlunotot). Israeli insurers are required by CMISA regulations to have a formal complaints process. Your complaint should:

• Identify the policy number and claim reference
• Clearly state why the denial is incorrect
• Reference the relevant provision of the Insurance Contract Law 1981 if applicable
• Attach all supporting evidence
• Request a written response within 30 days

Step 3: Escalate to the Financial Ombudsman (Pa'ar Ha'Din)

If your internal complaint does not result in a satisfactory resolution, you can escalate to the Financial Ombudsman of Israel (Pa'ar Ha'Din). This body provides free, independent dispute resolution for financial services complaints, including insurance.

How to contact the Financial Ombudsman:

• Website: https://www.paarhadin.co.il
• Phone: 077-7887799
• Address: 1 Azrieli Center (Round Tower), Tel Aviv, Israel

Eligibility:

• You must first have filed an internal complaint with your insurer and received its final response (or waited at least 30 days).
• The complaint must be within the ombudsman's subject matter jurisdiction (most insurance disputes qualify).

Process:

• File your complaint through the ombudsman's online portal or by mail.
• The ombudsman will investigate and attempt mediation.
• The ombudsman can issue a recommendation or, for disputes below a certain monetary threshold, a binding decision.

The Pa'ar Ha'Din process is free for consumers and does not require legal representation.

Step 4: Complain to CMISA

If the complaint involves a systemic issue — for example, the insurer is applying a policy exclusion that was never properly disclosed, or is failing to pay valid claims — file a formal complaint with CMISA through the *3002 hotline or the CMISA website. CMISA can investigate the insurer and impose regulatory sanctions.

Step 5: Civil Court Proceedings

For disputes that the ombudsman cannot resolve (for example, because the claim amount exceeds the ombudsman's jurisdiction or because the insurer refuses to comply with a recommendation), the Magistrates Court (Beit Mishpat HaShalom) or District Court has jurisdiction over insurance contract disputes. Consider engaging an Israeli attorney specializing in insurance law.

---

Car Insurance in Israel: Special Rules

Motor insurance in Israel is divided into two types:

1. Bituach Chova (Mandatory Third-Party Insurance): Covers bodily injury to third parties under the Road Accident Victims Compensation Law 1975. Claims under Bituach Chova go through a specialized legal framework. If your Bituach Chova claim is denied, file a complaint with CMISA and consider engaging a personal injury attorney.

2. Bituach Makif (Comprehensive Coverage): This is voluntary comprehensive motor insurance. Disputes about vehicle damage, theft, or total loss under Makif coverage go through the standard complaint process described above.

Vehicle valuation disputes: If you dispute the insurer's assessment of the value of a damaged or stolen vehicle, you are entitled to appoint your own assessor (Shama'i). If the two assessors disagree, the matter typically goes to an agreed-upon third assessor. This process is governed by most Israeli motor policies.

---

Health Insurance Supplemental Coverage

Israel provides universal basic health coverage through the four national health funds (Kupot Cholim). However, supplemental (Mashlim) and extended (Shoham) insurance policies sold by insurance companies to top up Kupah coverage are regulated by CMISA.

Common supplemental insurance denials:

• Claims for treatments available through the Kupah (basic coverage) — supplemental insurance typically only covers costs beyond what the Kupah provides
• Claims for treatments abroad when local treatment was available
• Pre-existing condition disputes

If your supplemental health insurance claim is denied, use the Pa'ar Ha'Din (ombudsman) process, which has specific experience with health insurance supplement disputes.

---

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Filing in Hebrew only when you need an English translation. If your claim materials are in English (for example, if you are an immigrant or have overseas medical records), consider providing Hebrew translations. Regulatory bodies and courts operate primarily in Hebrew.

Not requesting the insurer's internal complaint response in writing. You need a written final response from the insurer before approaching the ombudsman. If the insurer does not respond within 30 days, document this and proceed.

Missing the limitation period. Insurance claims in Israel are subject to a limitation period under the Limitation Law 1958 — generally three years. Do not delay legal action unnecessarily.

---

Drafting Your Appeal Letter

A formal insurance appeal letter in Israel should reference the Insurance Contract Law 1981, address the specific denial ground, and present your evidence clearly. ClaimBack at claimback.app can generate a professional, structured appeal letter tailored to your specific situation in Israel, helping you make the strongest possible case to your insurer and to the ombudsman.

---

Conclusion

Israel's insurance regulatory framework — anchored by CMISA, the Insurance Contract Law 1981, and the Pa'ar Ha'Din (financial ombudsman) — gives policyholders real, practical tools to challenge unfair claim denials. The ombudsman process is free, accessible, and has genuine authority. Exhaust internal complaints first, then use the ombudsman, and if necessary escalate to CMISA or the courts. For a professionally drafted appeal letter in English, visit ClaimBack at claimback.app.