Insurance Claim Denied in New Zealand: Your FSCL and FMA Rights

An insurance claim denied New Zealand isn't final. New Zealand has one of the world's clearest dispute resolution systems, with independent ombudsmen that can order insurers to pay. This guide shows you exactly how to appeal and win.

The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) oversees all insurers. The Financial Services Complaints Limited (FSCL) is your independent ombudsman. Together, they give you strong protections.

Here's your complete roadmap.

Your Rights in New Zealand's Insurance System

New Zealand's system is designed to be consumer-friendly:

FSCL (Financial Services Complaints Limited): The independent ombudsman for financial services complaints. Free, impartial, can award compensation up to NZD 350,000.

FMA (Financial Markets Authority): Regulates all insurers, brokers, and intermediaries. Sets conduct standards.

Insurance Act 2010: Requires insurers to act fairly and transparently.

Fair Insurance Code: Industry code setting standards for claims handling.

Right to Internal Dispute Resolution: Every insurer must have a formal process.

Right to FSCL Escalation: You can escalate any complaint that isn't resolved internally.

The system is straightforward and fair. Use it.

Step 1: Understand Your Denial

Your insurer must provide a detailed written explanation. If you don't have one, request it in writing.

The explanation must:

• Quote the specific policy clause or condition
• Explain how your claim doesn't meet that clause
• Reference the evidence reviewed
• Show they considered your circumstances
• Include information about how to escalate

If vague, that's a red flag. Push for clarity.

Keep this letter. It's the foundation of your appeal.

Step 2: Use the Insurer's Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR) Process

Every insurer in New Zealand must have a formal IDR process. Use it.

Timeline: The insurer must provide a written IDR response within 20 working days (or 1 month for complex cases).

How to Lodge:

1. Write to the insurer's IDR Department
2. State: "I am lodging a formal Internal Dispute Resolution complaint"
3. Include: policy number, claim number, date of denial, why you believe it's wrong
4. Attach new evidence: medical reports, doctor's letters, policy analysis
5. Send by registered mail or email with read receipt

What to Include:

• Clear statement you're formally disputing the decision
• Reference to the denial letter
• Specific policy clauses you believe support your claim
• Medical evidence or documentation
• Factual, professional tone
• Request for written IDR response

What Happens:

• The insurer acknowledges receipt
• They review your new evidence and original claim file
• Within 20 working days (or 1 month for complex cases), they provide a written IDR response
• The response explains their decision and includes FSCL escalation information

Possible Outcomes:

• Claim approved (success!)
• Denial upheld with explanation
• Partial settlement or compromise

If they uphold the denial, you now have the right to escalate to FSCL.

Step 3: Escalate to FSCL (Financial Services Complaints Limited)

If the insurer rejects your IDR complaint (or doesn't respond within the required timeframe), you can escalate to FSCL for free.

What is FSCL? FSCL is New Zealand's independent ombudsman for all financial services complaints. They're impartial, funded by the industry but operate independently, and have real authority over insurers.

FSCL's Authority:

• Can award compensation up to NZD 350,000
• Can overturn insurer decisions
• Decisions are binding on the insurer
• You can choose not to accept FSCL's decision and pursue court action (though this is rare)

How to Complain to FSCL:

1. Visit fscl.org.nz
2. Complete the online complaint form
3. Provide: your details, insurer name, policy number, claim number, what happened, why you disagree, supporting documents
4. Attach: IDR response letter, denial letter, medical evidence, policy document, other supporting materials
5. Submit

What FSCL Will Do:

• Acknowledge your complaint
• Request the insurer's file and response
• Review both sides independently
• Issue a decision with reasons
• If in your favour, order the insurer to pay the claim plus compensation

Timeline: Most complaints are resolved within 4-6 months. Simpler cases can be faster.

Cost: Completely free.

Step 4: ACC Claims (Accident Compensation)

If your claim involves personal injury from an accident, you may have ACC coverage instead of (or in addition to) private insurance.

What is ACC? The Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) provides no-fault accident insurance for all New Zealand residents and visitors. It covers treatment for injury from accidents.

IFSO (Insurance and Financial Services Ombudsman): For ACC complaints, you may escalate to the Insurance and Financial Services Ombudsman (IFSO).

Check if your situation involves ACC. You might have a claim there in addition to your private insurance claim.

Common Denial Reasons in New Zealand—And How to Challenge Them

"Pre-existing condition": The insurer says your condition existed before the policy. Counter with: doctor's letter with dates, medical records showing timeline, evidence you disclosed what was required, policy definition of "pre-existing."

"Not medically necessary": The insurer claims the treatment wasn't clinically justified. Fight back with: doctor's letter explaining necessity, medical guidelines (New Zealand Medical Association, specialist colleges), evidence similar patients receive treatment.

"Exclusion applies": The insurer says a policy exclusion covers your situation. Counter with: policy wording that contradicts this, medical evidence showing treatment for a covered condition, industry standards interpretation.

"Waiting period not met": Your claim is for something with a waiting period. This is hard to overturn unless the period wasn't clearly disclosed.

"Insufficient documentation": Ask exactly what's missing. Then provide it. If vague, that weakens their position.

Evidence That Wins FSCL Cases

Build a compelling evidence pack:

Medical Evidence:

• Doctor's letter addressing the denial reason
• All medical records and test results
• Specialist opinion (if applicable)
• NZ medical guidelines supporting the treatment
• International guidelines (if NZ guidance is limited)
• Evidence the condition was when you say it was

Policy Analysis:

• Full policy document with relevant clauses highlighted
• Schedule of benefits
• Comparison showing similar claims approved
• Communications from the insurer about coverage

Documentation:

• Your IDR complaint letter
• The insurer's IDR response
• Email correspondence
• Timeline of events
• Proof of how you submitted the claim

Expert Opinion:

• Doctor's detailed letter
• Specialist opinion
• References to treatment guidelines
• Evidence of standard medical practice in NZ

Writing Your FSCL Complaint

Your complaint must be clear, specific, and well-organized.

Structure:

1. What happened (brief chronology)
2. Why you believe the denial is wrong (specific policy references, medical evidence)
3. What Insurance Act 2010 requirements the insurer may have breached
4. What outcome you're seeking
5. All supporting documents attached

Keep it professional. Facts only. Let evidence speak.

ClaimBack can analyse your case and write your complaint letter in minutes — Start Free →

We'll analyze your denial, your policy, your medical records, and New Zealand insurance law, then generate a professional letter that FSCL reviewers take seriously.

Understanding the Fair Insurance Code

New Zealand's Fair Insurance Code sets standards for claims handling. Insurers must:

• Handle claims promptly
• Make decisions based on policy and facts
• Give clear reasons for denials
• Treat you fairly
• Have a proper complaints process

If your insurer breached the Fair Insurance Code, that's a violation that strengthens your case with FSCL.

Timeline for Appeal in New Zealand

• IDR response: 20 working days (1 month for complex cases)
• FSCL investigation: 4-6 months
• Total: 3-6 months in most cases

This is relatively fast. During this time, try to avoid paying disputed medical bills.

If You Used a Broker or Agent

If you purchased through a broker or agent:

• They also have responsibilities for fair dealing
• They can be liable if they misrepresented coverage
• You can complain about the broker/agent to the FMA and FSCL

If the broker/agent caused the problem, include this in your complaint.

Special Note: Travel Insurance

If your claim is for travel insurance:

• The IDR process still applies
• FSCL still has jurisdiction
• But some travel insurance policies have specific exclusions worth checking carefully
• Medical evidence is particularly important for medical claims while traveling

Pre-Appeal Checklist

• I have my denial letter with detailed reasoning
• I have filed an IDR complaint and received the response
• I have gathered all medical evidence
• I have my full policy document highlighted with relevant clauses
• I have considered whether ACC applies (for accident claims)
• I have organized all evidence chronologically
• I have visited fscl.org.nz and reviewed the process
• I have drafted a clear, evidence-backed complaint
• I have proof of how I'm submitting (registered mail or email)

New Zealand's system is designed to be fair and straightforward. Use it.

---

Disclaimer: ClaimBack provides AI-generated appeal assistance for informational purposes only. ClaimBack is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Always review your appeal letter before sending and consider professional advice for complex or high-value claims. Regulatory processes vary — always verify current procedures with your insurer or regulator.

---

Ready to fight your denial? ClaimBack analyses your case and writes a professional appeal letter in minutes — Start Free →